Acne and breakouts

Types of Acne Scars: How to Identify Yours, and What Treats Each

Ice pick, boxcar and rolling scars, raised scars, and the red and brown marks that aren't scars at all.

Types of Acne Scars: How to Identify Yours, and What Treats Each
On this page

"Acne scars" covers several different things, and the treatment that works depends on which you have. True scars are changes in the skin's structure: either a loss of tissue, leaving a dent, or an excess, leaving a raised area. The red and brown marks that follow a spot are not scars. They're flat, and they fade. Working out which you have saves a lot of wasted effort.

First: is it a scar or a mark?

Run a fingertip over the area, or look at it in light coming from the side.

Texture Colour Fades by itself?
Red marks (post-inflammatory erythema) Flat Pink, red, purple Yes, over months
Brown marks (post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation) Flat Brown, grey-brown Yes, over months to a year or more
Atrophic scars Indented Skin-coloured, sometimes red or brown at first No
Hypertrophic and keloid scars Raised Pink, red, brown or skin-coloured Rarely

If your marks are flat, see post-inflammatory erythema for red marks and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation for brown ones. Skincare works on those.

Atrophic (indented) scars

These form when inflammation destroys collagen and the skin heals with too little tissue. They're the most common type on the face, and dermatologists divide them into three kinds.

Ice pick scars

  • Look: narrow, deep holes, as if the skin had been pierced with a sharp point. Usually under 2mm across.
  • Where: cheeks, most often.
  • Why they're difficult: they extend deep into the skin, so surface treatments don't reach the base.

Boxcar scars

  • Look: round or oval depressions with sharp, defined, vertical edges, like chickenpox scars. Wider than ice pick scars, and shallow or deep.
  • Where: cheeks and temples.

Rolling scars

  • Look: broad depressions with sloping, soft edges that give the skin a wavy, uneven look. They're more obvious in side lighting and with age, as skin loses firmness.
  • Why: fibrous bands under the skin pull the surface down.
  • Test: if stretching the skin makes them nearly disappear, they're rolling scars.

Most people have a mix.

Free toolSkincare routine builderNot sure what order to use your products in?Open the routine builder →

Hypertrophic and keloid scars

These form when the skin makes too much collagen as it heals.

  • Hypertrophic scars are raised and firm, and stay within the area of the original spot. They may flatten over time.
  • Keloids grow beyond the original spot and don't shrink. They can itch or be tender.

Both are more common on the jawline, chest, shoulders and back, and in people with brown and black skin. They can run in families.

What treats each type

Scar treatment is done by dermatologists and trained practitioners. This table shows what's typically used.

Scar type Treatments commonly used
Ice pick TCA CROSS (a strong acid placed precisely into each scar); punch excision
Boxcar Laser resurfacing; microneedling; punch techniques; TCA CROSS for narrow ones
Rolling Subcision (releasing the bands beneath); fillers; microneedling; laser
Hypertrophic Silicone gel or sheets; steroid injections
Keloid Steroid injections; silicone; sometimes cryotherapy. Surgery alone often leads to regrowth

A review of acne scar treatment lists chemical peels, dermabrasion, laser, punch techniques, needling and combined approaches for atrophic scars, and silicone gels, steroid injections, cryotherapy and surgery for raised ones.

Things to know before pursuing treatment:

  • Results are improvement, not erasure. A good outcome is scars that are noticeably shallower.
  • Several sessions are usually needed, often with combined methods.
  • Darker skin tones carry a higher risk of pigment changes from lasers and peels. Choose a practitioner with experience of your skin tone.
  • Acne must be under control first. Treating scars while new ones form is pointless.
  • In the UK, scar treatment is generally considered cosmetic and isn't routinely available on the NHS. Check a practitioner's qualifications and registration.
  • Recent isotretinoin treatment affects timing. Tell your practitioner.
Related guideTypes of Acne: How to Identify Your Spots, and What Treats EachBlackheads, whiteheads, papules, pustules, nodules and cysts explained. How to tell which spots you have, how severity is judged, and the right treatment.Read the guide →

What skincare can do

Be realistic. No cream fills a dent.

  • Retinoids (prescription tretinoin or adapalene; over-the-counter retinol) stimulate collagen and smooth the surface. Over many months they can soften shallow scars slightly, and they prevent new spots.
  • AHAs such as glycolic acid smooth surface texture, which makes shallow scars a little less obvious.
  • Vitamin C supports collagen formation.
  • Sunscreen stops scars and marks from darkening, and protects collagen.
  • Silicone gel helps flatten new raised scars.

Skincare is very effective for the flat red and brown marks, and those often make up much of what people call scarring.

Home microneedling devices are a different matter from professional treatment. Short needles do little, long ones risk infection and more scarring. They're not recommended.

Preventing scars

This matters more than any treatment.

  1. Treat acne early and properly. Scarring risk rises the longer inflamed acne goes on. If over-the-counter products haven't worked in 12 weeks, see a GP.
  2. Don't pick or squeeze. See why you shouldn't pop spots.
  3. Get help quickly for deep, painful spots. Nodules and cysts are the lesions most likely to scar. See cystic acne.
  4. Use spot patches to protect healing spots. See pimple patches.
  5. Wear sunscreen.

NICE advises referral to a dermatologist for acne that's scarring.

When to see a GP

  • You have active acne that's leaving scars
  • You have raised or growing scars
  • Scarring is affecting your confidence or mental health

References

Jacob CI, Dover JS, Kaminer MS. Acne scarring: a classification system and review of treatment options. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2001;45(1):109-117. (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11423843/)

Fabbrocini G, Annunziata MC, D'Arco V, De Vita V, et al. Acne scars: pathogenesis, classification and treatment. Dermatol Res Pract. 2010;2010:893080. (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20981308/)

National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Acne vulgaris: management. NICE guideline NG198. (https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ng198)

FAQs

What are the three types of acne scars?

The three indented types are ice pick, boxcar and rolling scars. Raised scars are hypertrophic or keloid.

Do acne scars go away?

Red and brown marks fade. Indented and raised scars are permanent without treatment, though they can soften with time.

Can skincare get rid of acne scars?

It fades marks and can slightly soften shallow scars. Indented scars need professional procedures.

What is the best treatment for ice pick scars?

TCA CROSS or punch excision, done by a professional.

Does retinol help acne scars?

Slightly, for shallow scars, over many months. It helps more by preventing new spots.

How do I know if I have scars or hyperpigmentation?

If the area is flat and only differs in colour, it's a mark. If it's indented or raised, it's a scar.